Those documents contain, among other things, information about why two Chinese-national senior scientists at the National Microbiology Laboratory (NML) facility in Winnipeg, Manitoba, together with several of their Chinese-national students, were physically removed in early July 2019 and the two senior scientists were fired in January 2021.
The students and staff reportedly were dismissed because of national-security concerns. Their security clearances were revoked in July 2019, they were not allowed to return to the lab and are being investigated by the RCMP.
Most of the scrutiny is on one of those two senior NML scientists, Xianggou Qiu [pronounced ‘choo’]. She and her husband Keding Cheng were the duo fired by the NML in January 2021.
But when Trudeau called the election in mid-August, that took the heat off him and his party with respect to the Qiu-NML scandal: media focused instead on the frenetic campaigning.
And there’s been almost complete silence, on the part of Trudeau and the Liberals and all the other federal political parties, since then about this critically important issue .
Thanks to information from a source with knowledge of some of the innermost workings of the NML while Qiu was there -- who approached me with key information in exchange for anonymity -- I have been able to put together a reasonably clear picture of why all the political parties are keeping the lid on this during the election.
It seems likely that valuable, made-in-Canada, vaccine technology was illicitly transferred to China by some of the staff at the NML, in plain sight. The NML is part of the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) – the branch of the federal government that among other things also oversees the country’s Covid response.
This made-in-Canada vaccine technology, in turn, has directly contributed to a Chinese company called CanSino Biologics Inc. making hundreds of millions of dollars in profit from the sale of a Covid vaccine based on that technology. This big haul likely is being shared with CanSino’s partners, the Chinese government and military.
Public outcry has been largely curbed, however – and this is helped by influential individuals. One recent example is this July 14, 2021, Globe and Mail article by Christopher Parsons of the University of Toronto’s Citizen Lab (which is funded in part by the infamous Ford Foundation and George Soros’s Open Society Institute). In his opinion piece, Parsons argues that security-risk assessments of foreign scientists who receive funding from the Canadian government is a bad idea because such assessment would “chill research and scholarly training, accentuate anti-immigrant biases and may amplify national security problems.”
Here is a ten-point summary of the evidence for the deliberate but surreptitious transfer of key Canadian vaccine tech to China. I got most of this information from my source, and I elaborate on it all later in the article. It's largely circumstantial but still makes a clear case:
It’s also worth mentioning -- even if it may appear to most readers to be peripheral to this story -- that an NML project to develop another type of Ebola vaccine, VSV- ZEBOV, was more successful than Ad5-EBOV. Judie Alimonti was the head of that project and successfully brought VSV-ZEBOV into clinical use: it was chosen over many others to be used on an emergency basis in Africa in 2014. However, Alimonti was given virtually no credit for this: Qiu and Kobinger were credited instead. And the vaccine was subsequently sold to Merck (which renamed it Ervebo).
A book published on August 14 -- one day before Trudeau announced the start of the current federal election campaign – played a significant role, I believe, in helping cover up the truth of what happened at the NML in Winnipeg. [The book also supports the Official Narrative about Covid being very dangerous, and it ignores the gaping holes in that narrative.]
Elaine Dewar’s 470-page book, On the Origin of the Deadliest Pandemic in 100 Years: An Investigation, appears on the surface to be a deep dive into where Covid came from. Dewar concludes toward the end of her book that the novel coronavirus was created in a laboratory in Wuhan, China, and was released accidentally or on purpose from there.
Dewar researched and wrote the book in just one year, and it was published within just two months of her finishing it. It also received laudatory and high-profile coverage: for example this August 31 report by the CBC’s Karen Pauls.
Dewar discusses at some length in her book the vials of Ebola and other dangerous materials that Qiu sent to the Wuhan Institute of Virology in March 2019. Yet overall she paints Qiu as being innocent of any deliberate wrongdoing.
Dewar also largely takes at face value statements by Kobinger exonerating Qiu. For example Dewar quotes Kobinger as saying he believes Qiu and her husband were removed from the NML because of “other issues that are completely unrelated to scientific research” – that is, revenge by Canada for the December 2018 arrest in China of the ‘two Michaels,’ Spavor and Kovrig (p. 168).
In addition, Dewar never mentions any of the evidence pointing to Ad5-EBOV possibly having been transferred from the NML to China.
Ad5-EBOV contains an adenovirus into which the scientists spliced the gene for the Ebola virus’s spike protein. (The adenovirus has been manipulated so that it is not able to replicate.) The spike protein is therefore produced in the vaccine recipient’s body and is intended to elicit an antibody response specific to Ebola.
Qiu, who was born in China, received her MD at Hebei Medical University in 1985 and an MSc in 1990. In 1996 she left China and moved to Houston, Texas, to do research at the MD Anderson Cancer Center. Qiu moved to Winnipeg the following year and in 2003 was hired by the NML.
Qiu’s research at the NML was conducted primarily by a large number of visiting students and scientists from China. My source told me that Qiu’s work was largely unknown to people working in other laboratories at the NML. Other NML scientists’ role was largely limited to writing some of Qiu’s pre-2015 research papers -- her ability to speak and write English was very limited until after that.
Qiu together with Kobinger, as well as other researchers from the NML and additional institutions in the U.S. and Canada, worked on adenovirus-based Ebola vaccines, primarily the Ad5-ZEBOV. They published approximately 12 papers on this research between 2006 and 2015.
Remarkably, the adenovirus-vaccine research project was never officially recognized by the NML. See for example this document listing news articles on the work of Qiu at the NML: there is no mention in any of the articles of the adenovirus-vaccine project.
“If this work was successful, why no mention by PHAC or the NML publicly? Not even a single press release or more importantly no patent application,” my source wrote in an email to me. “And if it was failing, why continue to work on it for so long? I believe it’s because this vaccine and the adenovirus platform for it were never destined to go from NML/PHAC to Canada, for Canada.”
All four papers were authored by, among others, scientists from China’s Academy of Military Medical Sciences in Beijing – which is an arm of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army or PLA, and which also is a partner of CanSino’s in developing its Ad5-based vaccines (see points 6 and 7, below). In addition, some of the students working with Qiu at the NML were from the Academy (see point 4, below).
The first, second and fourth papers also are co-authored by, among others, researchers from CanSino.
Furthermore, Qiu is a co-author of the first of those four papers – and not just any co-author, but the last author. This position in the author line-up is usually reserved for the person who is the senior/managing scientist for the study. And indeed, Qiu’s PHAC/NML email address is supplied; this indicates she is the point/contact person for the paper.
Qiu and Kobinger received a lot of press about their ZMapp research, and they were given awards for it. These included the Governor General’s Innovation Award in 2018. The pair were congratulated for receiving this award by, among many others, PHAC official and Chief Public Health Officer of Canada Theresa Tam (see Tam’s May 23, 2018, tweet).
However, the results of a clinical trial of ZMapp published in 2016 in the New England Journal of Medicine showed it was not effective against Ebola. ZMapp subsequently sank largely out of sight in the medical literature, except for appearances such as in a 2019 paper that showed ZMapp is inferior to other Ebola treatments.
“The ZMapp project could be viewed as a beautiful cover for what Qiu and Kobinger were also doing -- which was developing an Ebola vaccine based on the adenovirus platform without its being an official/high-profile NML project,” my source told me in a telephone interview. “ZMapp failed in that first clinical trial, published in 2016, and was never used in the field again because it was not effective at all. Yet this is supposedly what Qiu and Kobinger were beavering away on for about 10 years, to great fanfare.”
According to my source, Qiu made several trips to China every year, starting in at least 2010, if not before. Each trip lasted two to eight weeks. Qiu was somewhat evasive and non-specific about the purpose of her trips; according to my source, Qiu usually told others at the NML that her trips were to visit family, to do research or to attend conferences.
Dany Shoham, an Israeli army officer and a biomedical researcher at the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies at Bar Ilan Universities, has probed Qiu’s Chinese ties. In a December 2019 article Shoham documented that Qiu had Chinese-national students working for her at the NML who were from army and state facilities such as China’s Academy of Military Medical Sciences (which, as pointed out in point 2 above, is an arm of the People’s Liberation Army of the Chinese Communist Party), the China CDC, the Wuhan Institute of Virology and the Institute of Microbiology at the Chinese Academy of Sciences.
Shoham also documented that Qiu had received grants from many Chinese institutions, ranging from the National Key Program for Infectious Disease of China to the National Key Research and Development Program of China.
And a July 2021 investigative piece on CBC News pointed to Qiu’s students having ties to China’s Academy of Military Medical Sciences.
The CBC investigation also indicated that some security experts and politicians are concerned by such individuals having been given federal security clearance to work on nationally important and sensitive projects at the NML. These included sources who told CBC that non-Canadian citizens sometimes have limitations to their security clearance but that in some cases those limitations were ignored for Qiu’s students.
According to a June 23, 2021, National Post article by Tom Blackwell, who broke this story, a spokesperson for PHAC refused to comment on whether Qiu sought the required permission from the government to file these patents or whether PHAC was even aware of the patents.
Blackwell quotes a prominent trade and R&D lawyer, Mark Warner, as saying, “’If her [Qiu’s] contract permitted it, that would be a scandal. If the contract didn’t permit it and they ignored the contract, that would be a scandal. If the contract didn’t even turn its attention to this, that would be a scandal, too.’”
Blackwell wrote that the spokesperson said, when he asked whether PHAC is concerned about working in such a way with the Chinese government, that “'open science and collaboration’ are core to its work.”
The official story is the vaccine had been discovered, at some unspecified time, by the Chinese Academy of Military Medical Sciences' Institute of Biotechnology, and was being co-developed with CanSino. (As noted in point 2 above, that Academy is an arm of the PLA.)
The clinical trials were in 2014-2015. The vaccine was approved by the China FDA in October 2017 (see the fourth row -- labelled ‘Ad5-EBOV (monovalent)’ -- fourth column, point c, in this World Health Organization table summarizing the Ebola vaccines in development as of Aug. 19, 2019; and see this page of the CanSino website on the timeline for its Ebola vaccine).
CanSino was founded in 2009 by Chinese citizen Xuefeng Yu. He did a PhD at McGill and later became head of vaccine development and production at Sanofi Pasteur in Toronto. CanSino’s CFO Zhu Tao also was a senior scientist at Sanofi Pasteur. CanSino’s name connotes the Canadian-Chinese connections that led to the creation of the company.
A December 2020 Global TV investigative report (also uploaded to my website here) by Sam Cooper shows that the Canadian Security and Intelligence Service (CSIS) suspects Zhu and Yu of having been part of a concerted espionage campaign by the Chinese government. That campaign -- known as the ‘Thousand Talents’ plan – focuses on transferring R&D and intellectual property from countries like Canada, the US and Australia to China.
The Plan was started in 2008 by the Chinese Communist Party. According to the Global TV report, ‘Thousand Talents’ is “deeply intertwined with China’s broad espionage campaigns.” Zhu apparently was recruited in December 2010.
An April 2017 English-language article in the Chinese publication ‘Sixth Tone’ praises the company’s lightening-speed development of their adenovirus-based Ebola vaccine. It also notes that a CanSino board member and investment banker named Nisa Leung believes CanSino will “become a global player in the vaccine market. ‘The Ebola vaccine is a good thing, but vaccines for children are more important, and there’s a bigger market — that’s why there’s so much support from everywhere,’ Leung said.”
CanSino raised tens of millions of dollars in 2015 from companies such as Eli Lilly to scale up production of its Ad5-EBOV vaccine.
According to a July 2020 Bloomberg News article, CanSino “raced through pre-clinical studies on the[ir] coronavirus vaccine – called Ad5-nCoV.” (That same article also gives glowing praise to Yu and other of “this new breed of executives” trained in other countries and who return to China to build companies with the expertise and knowledge they gained abroad.)
As with the Ebola vaccine based on the adenovirus serotype 5, the results were mixed -- in part because almost everyone already has antibodies to this virus, which is one of the viruses that cause the common cold.
An August 27, 2021, Reuters article indicates that in the first six months of 2021 CanSino had an operating profit of $123.79 million USD, “driven by use of its COVID-19 shot.”
Meanwhile, the NML -- where this very valuable vaccine technology likely originated -- over the years has been hollowed out with respect to funding. And its leading figures have all left for other positions across North America or, in Alimonti’s case, passed away.